Best Crib Mattress 2022 Reviews and Buying Guide

As a loving parent, it is truly pertinent to provide your child with everything he or she will ever need. There is an abundance of different items that parents must purchase for their children and a crib is undoubtedly one of the most vital.

Unfortunately, buying a crib can be complex and requires a lot of diligence on your end. Within this comprehensive guide, you’ll not only read the reviews of the best crib mattress but also learn precisely what to look for when choosing a mattress for your new crib.

9 of the Best Crib Mattresses

My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Crib Mattress

The My First Mattress is a very high-quality brand that offers superior comfort and safety. It meets all of the American and European standards for emission, durability, and chemical content after undergoing a thorough accredited testing process.

This is a universal crib mattress that measures 51-5/8” L X 27-1/4” X 5” in thickness, which fits the basic requirements. Below, you will discover the most notable specifications of this crib mattress.

Notable Specifications

The My First Mattress is designed to promote safety in every aspect. The extra-firm support will prevent the mattress from sinking in, even when the child reaches the 3-year milestone.

The high-density foam and other materials utilized in the construction are hypoallergenic, lead and phthalate-free, so you can rest assure that your baby will be totally safe at all times.

<<<<<<<< Check latest price on >>>>>>>>

  • Mite-proof and anti-microbial design
  • Includes a removable waterproof cover that is labeled machine washable
  • Polyurethane foam is CertiPUR-US certified for safety
  • Extremely affordable
  • Corners are square for a perfectly snug fit
  • Comes with a 10-year limited manufacturer’s warranty
  • Shipped in a compact, vacuum packed package (requires environmental inflation)

Overall Assessment

Overall, the My First Mattress has one of the safest designs on the market. It is suitable for newborns and children up to 3 years of age, so you can rest assure that you are going to get your money’s worth out of this investment. 

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress

If you are on the market for a crib mattress that has an environmental friendly design, you should look no further than the Sealy Soybean. Not only does ASTM certify this mattress, but it is also Greenguard Gold certified.

The materials utilized in the construction have undergone an extensive testing process, which includes the durability, chemical content, firmness, and air quality. Below, you will discover the most notable specification of the Sealy Soybean crib mattress.

Notable Specifications

The Sealy Soybean’s craftsmanship is rated very highly. The seams are lock-stitched to prevent unraveling, even after extensive years of use. The layers of padding and soy foam are packed into a waterproof cover in a way that allows air to circulate throughout the mattress.This feature alone will ensure the longevity of the mattress, while preventing bacteria and mold growth.

<<<<<<<< Check latest price on >>>>>>>>

  • Includes a lifetime manufacturer’s warranty
  • ASTM and Greenguard Gold certified for environmental safety
  • Embedded with cotton wrap cushioning for comfort
  • Outer covering is waterproof, stain-resistant, and pearl embossed
  • Can be washed down, using a damp cloth and mild detergent
  • Measurements – 52” L X 28” W X 5” thickness
  • Square corner design for a perfectly snug fit
  • Materials are phthalate-fee and flame retardant

Overall Assessment

Overall, the Sealy Soybean is rated one of the best mattresses on the market and to prove it, in 2013, the pads alone received the Women’s Choice Award. The design provides the child with a comfortable, safe, and environmental friendly sleeping environment. It is also very important to note that this crib mattress is manufactured in the United States, which says enough about its craftsmanship and quality. 

Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 Crib Mattress

A crib mattress should not break the bank, but it should offer superior safety and comfort. The Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 will offer these benefits and so much more.

This very affordable crib mattress is constructed with 5 layers of materials that are flame retardant, lead and phthalate free. It has also been put through rigorous safety testing, which it passed easily and certified by ASTM. Below, you will discover the most notable specifications of the Kolcraft Pure Sleep crib mattress.

Notable Specifications

The innerspring coils embedded into the mattress are constructed out of heavy-duty steel, plus they are heat tempered for superior bounce-back action. The 150 high coil count also keeps the coils closer together for an ultra-firm sleeping surface.

It is important to note that this mattress is slightly heavier than many of the competitor brands, but this is normal with coil mattresses.

<<<<<<<< Check latest price on >>>>>>>>

  • Embedded with high-density (1-1/2 pounds/cubic feet) polyurethane foam
  • Outer covering is waterproof and can be cleaned with a damp cloth and mild soap
  • Interior cushioning is constructed out of environmental materials
  • Manufactured in the United States
  • Includes a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty (materials and workmanship)
  • Sides are lock-stitched for antimicrobial and waterproof protection
  • Extremely affordable price tag

Overall Assessment

Do not be fooled by the low price tag, because the Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 will offer the same, if not more benefits than the expensive brand. This crib mattress carries a Greenguard certified rating that ensures a healthy and safe sleeping environment. 

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress

The Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer crib mattress is slightly more expensive than many of the competitor brands, but there are many reasons for this. The limited lifetime manufacturer’s warranty will definitely make the price tag a little friendlier.

The overall construction of the Little Dreamer makes it stand above the rest, plus it specially treated to prevent microbial growth. Below, you will discover the most notable specifications of the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer crib mattress.

Notable Specifications

The sides have been stitched very tightly to prevent unraveling and for antimicrobial protection, even after many years of use. The materials utilized in the design are Certi-PUR-US certified for environmental safety.

<<<<<<<< Check latest price on >>>>>>>>

  • Measurements – 52” L X 27-1/2” W X 5” thickness (standard)
  • Outer layering is designed with vinyl and PVC free materials
  • 250 Pound weight capacity
  • Dual-sided design allows for use with newborns and toddlers
  • Square corner design for a secure fit
  • Waterproof outer covering, which can be clean, using a damp cloth and mild soap
  • Lightweight construction

Overall Assessment

Overall, the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer is to offer various benefits with safety being the main one. The dual-sided design will allow the child to utilize the mattress for a much longer period of time, plus the newborn side is extra-firm for SIDS protection.

Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Mattress

The Simmons Kids Beautyrest is a truly great mattress that promotes comfort and safety. The dual-purpose design along with the convoluted layer provides the upmost comfort and firmness for newborns. The mattress is also equipped with a fire protection wrap and medical-grade waterproof barrier.

You can rest assured that your baby will stay day all night long. The Beautyrest mattress measures 52” L X 27-1/2” W X 6” thickness and weighs around 26 pounds. Below, you will discover the most notable specifications for this crib mattress.

Notable Specifications

The Beautyrest mattress was designed with your baby’s safety and comfort in mind. The mattress is Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US certified, so you can rest assured that this it is environmentally safe. The 231-pocketed coils springs provide the most comfortable sleeping surface possible. 

<<<<<<<< Check latest price on >>>>>>>>

  • Limited lifetime warranty provides peace of mind
  • Medical-grade waterproof barrier ensures total dryness during the night hours
  • Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US certified
  • Reinforced border edge and Innofoam corners provides maximum stability and superior fit
  • Protection wrap constructed out of chemical-free materials

Overall Assessment

At the end of the day, this is truly a high-quality, affordable mattress that comes with a limited lifetime warranty. This should be enough to ease any parent’s mind. You really can rest assured that this mattress will provide your little one with comfort and safety.

Newton Crib Mattress

If you are looking to spend a little more on a crib mattress, you should definitely consider the Newton. It is designed to offer 100% breathability for antimicrobial protection. Most of the materials utilized in the construction are all recycle.

This mattress is unlike many of the other brands, in that pediatric physician, Dr. Jim Sears, has recommended it. Below, you will discover the most notable specifications of the Newton crib mattress.

Notable Specifications

The Newton mattress is dual-sided, so it will grow with the child. The infant side offers an ultra-firm sleeping surface, while the toddler side offers more softness and comfort. Believe it or not, this model has been listed in various popular magazines (TIME, ABC) and given the JPMA Innovation Award in 2015.

<<<<<<<< Check latest price on amazon >>>>>>>>

  • Greenguard certified for environmental safety
  • Outer covering is waterproof and completely machine washable (also replaceable)
  • Construction is latex, foam, coil spring, and glue free
  • Embedded with a superior air circulation system (prevents overheating)
  • Core contains 10% food-grade polymer
  • Non-halogenated flame retardant protection
  • Manufactured in the United States (Tennessee)
  • Includes a limited lifetime manufacturer’s warranty

Overall Assessment

Overall, the Newton crib mattress is one of the safest brands on the market. It is constructed out of all-recyclable material, which environmental sleeping surface. While it is never to invest more money in a crib mattress, you should definitely keep this model on your list of prospects.

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150 Mattress

Parents that are looking for an incredibly versatile crib mattress, which is also 100% organic, should look no further than the Naturepedic No Compromise Cotton Classic Mattress. This mattress, which is made in the United States, is finished with a waterproof surface.

Whether your child makes a mess or their bottle is spilled on the material, you’ll be able to wipe it clean quickly. This also helps to prevent moisture from penetrating the mattress and damaging it internally. This surface is completely non-toxic, so you’ll never have to worry about your child coming in contact with potentially harmful chemicals or toxins.

Notable Specifications

The Naturepedic No Compromise Classic 150 Mattress is much more costly than the alternatives, but its performance and specifications make it well worth it. This will be evident, when you examine the notable specifications below.

<<<<<<<< Check latest price on >>>>>>>>

  • Slightly heavier at 20 pounds
  • Meets Green Guard standards, so very little to no chemicals are emitted
  • 150 coils for sufficient support
  • Waterproof surface is easy to clean and non-toxic
  • Manufactured from 100% organic cotton in the United States
  • 2-stage dual firmness, which makes it compatible with babies and toddlers
  • Measures in at 6 by 27.8 by 52 inches

Overall Assessment

Although the price tag will ultimately make many parents steer clear of the Naturepedic, this is truly a mistake. The mattress may be expensive, but it is designed to last a lifetime and will never require you to expose your child to potentially harmful chemicals. In fact, it is truly an excellent value and is capable of growing with your baby into toddlerhood. 

Lullaby Earth Healthy Support Crib Mattress

If you’re looking for a well-rounded mattress, which will prove to be an excellent value, you should look no further than the Lullaby Earth Healthy Support Crib Mattress. The mattress is one of the most costly, but it comes with a limited lifetime warranty and is made in the United States.

The mattress is also lightweight and has an outer shell, which is waterproof. This helps to ensure that the mattress will lull your child to sleep and will last for an extensive period of time. If you want to keep your child away from phthalate, latex, lead and BPA, this could very well be the best mattress for you!

Notable Specifications

The Lullaby Earth Mattress is beneficial for parents and babies alike. It is lightweight and the standard size of a crib mattress, so you can guarantee it’ll fit the mass majority of cribs on the market. Additional specifications can be found below.

<<<<<<<< Check latest price on >>>>>>>>

  • Completely free of harmful materials, such as phthalate, latex, BPA and lead
  • Weighs 7 pounds and measures in at 28 by 6 by 52 inches
  • Outer material is waterproof
  • Delivers firm support
  • Protected by a limited lifetime warranty
  • Made in the United States
  • Equipped with Air-Core, which is an environmentally friendly support layer

Overall Assessment

All in all, the Lullaby Earth Mattress is an excellent option for parents, who refuse to take the risk of exposing their children to potentially toxic materials. Although the price is steep, the mattress delivers added peace of mind and immense value, thanks to its limited lifetime warranty. This makes it an excellent option for almost all parents. 

L A Baby Organic Cotton 2-in-1 Orthopedic Crib Mattress

The L A Baby Organic Cotton Mattress is a moderately affordable organic mattress. It is heavy duty and has a gauge rating of 15.5, which is perfect for toddlers. For additional support, the mattress is also fitted with a 9-gauge border rod.

The combination helps to ensure that the mattress is incredibly durable and will provide you toddler with plenty of support. The mattress is completely manufactured in the United States. Air vents are positioned on both sides to help keep the mattress cool to the touch.

Notable Specifications

The L A Baby Organic Mattress is capable of supporting all babies and is 100% certified organic. The mattress is safe, firm and well worth its price tag. For your consideration, the most notable specifications will be provided below.

<<<<<<<< Check latest price on >>>>>>>>

  • Mattress has two sides. One is suitable for newborns, while the other is great for toddlers
  • 100% USDA certified organic
  • Approximately 5 and a half inches thick
  • Capable of supporting 4 to 50 pounds of weight
  • Weighs 18 pounds
  • 260 steel Coils, which are 15.5 gauge
  • Lock stitching prevents splitting and stops moisture from entering the mattress
  • Mattress is treated with a flame retardant

Overall Assessment

Although the L A Baby Organic Cotton Mattress isn’t the cheapest product on the market, it does come with additional features that make it well worth the additional cost. The mattress is organic, has been treated with a flame retardant, and is superbly firm for a baby.

Choosing A Crib Mattress

Although the crib itself is important, you should never neglect the mattress. If the mattress isn’t suitable, it could actually become problematic and could transform into a hazard. In this category, it is truly pertinent to make sure you choose a mattress that is firm.

When you press on the mattress and remove your hand, very little to no indentation should be left behind. This will help to guarantee that your child will not sink into the mattress and suffocate! 

Foam Or Innerspring

When attempting to select a mattress for your crib, you’ll need to choose between an innerspring mattress and a foam mattress. Both can serve their intended purpose, but they’re different in a handful of ways. You’ll learn about both types below. 

Foam – Foam mattresses tend to be much less costly, but extra precautions need to be taken. Be sure to feel the mattress and make sure that the foam is firm enough to support your baby’s weight, without allowing him or her to sink in too far. 

Innerspring – These mattresses are much more costly, but they’ll last for a lengthier period of time and are also much safer. When opting for an innerspring mattress, you should try to find one that has 135 to 150 coils. The gauge of the mattress should be lower than 15.5. These classifications will help to ensure that the mattress is sufficiently firm for your toddler. 

Ticking Or Thick Cover

Another important aspect of your crib mattress is the ticking or the mattress’ cover. In order to acquire a very durable mattress, which will be much less likely to suffer from holes and tears, you should opt for one that has several layers of laminate coating. It is also a good idea to choose a mattress, in which the coating has been enhanced with nylon. 


Before purchasing your mattress, you need to confirm that it has been certified. Be sure to check the label and make sure that it has the designated CPSC certification. This confirms that the mattress has met or exceeded the quality and safety standards set forth by the CPSC, Consumer Product Safety Consumer, and will be safe for your toddler to use. 

Mattress Ventilation

In order to ensure that your baby will be able to sleep comfortably throughout the night, his or her crib needs to be properly ventilated. The mattress needs to have ventilation holes on both sides so that air can circulate through the mattress. This will not only keep your child comfortable and cool, but also it’ll help to eliminate odors by allowing them to escape.

Other Mattress Considerations

Over the years, a large variety of mattress varieties have become available. These include mattresses, which are manufactured from organic materials, as well as those that have flame retardant properties. Although these specific types are not absolutely vital, they can provide the parent with added peace of mind. You’ll learn about both types below. 

Organic – Organic mattresses are those that have been developed out of completely organic materials. Human-made chemicals are not present, so you can rest assured knowing your child will remain safe and won’t suffer from any allergic reactions. The only downfall associated with this type is the fact that the price will be immensely higher. 

Flame Retardant – It is possible to find organic and traditional mattresses, which are designed with flame-retardants. Although a fire risk is fairly minute, a flame retardant mattress will be much less hazardous. This isn’t an absolute necessity, but acquiring a mattress with this characteristic might be reassuring for some.

Considering A Crib Mattress Cover

Aside from the mattress, you should also contemplate the purchase of a mattress cover. Since the mattress itself won’t cost an arm and a leg, a cover is generally a good idea. Some mattresses will include a cover, but it is also possible to make the purchase additionally. Below, you’ll find a list of some of the mattress covers available to choose from. 

Waterproof – Can help protect the mattress from spills and urine

Hypoallergenic – These covers are capable of reducing allergens, which could result in allergic reactions 

It is also possible to purchase covers, which embody both characteristics. A good mattress cover is capable of protecting your mattress, providing your child with added comfort, and even eliminating noise from tossing and turning the child. Adding one to your child’s crib can be a great idea. 


Although bumpers are still readily available and still commonly sold in crib bedding sets, they’re not recommended! The American Academy of Pediatrics admits that crib bumpers can be enormously dangerous and drastically increase the risks of SIDS. 

Fancy Decorations

Some crib manufacturers go above and beyond to make their cribs unique and eye-catching. If the crib has knobs, columns, or some other decorative knickknack on the top ledge, the crib should be avoided.

This is the case because these items could easily break free and come crashing down onto the child. Also, they could become a choking hazard or could trap your child’s arm or neck. 

Avoid Clutter

Once you’ve finally acquired your crib and have it set up in your nursery, you should do your best to avoid cluttering the crib with unnecessary items. A small blanket should suffice. Hold off on pillows, toys, and other items, as they could become suffocation hazards. Keep the child’s face and neck area clear at all times. 

How To Make Your Child’s Crib Safe

Aside from reading crib mattress reviews and selecting the right make and model, it is also pertinent to make sure you transform your child’s crib into a safe environment. Some parents get off on the wrong foot right from the installation process. Below, you’ll find some ways to help establish a safe sleeping environment for your toddler. 

Nursery Position

Finding a good location for your crib is also important. It is a good idea to keep the crib away from windows and nightstands or dresser drawers. These items usually have cords and strings, whether associated with a baby monitor or drapes.

These items are very problematic and could get wrapped around the child’s hands, arms or neck. Place the crib out of reach of such items and you’ll be able to sleep soundly knowing your child cannot get into trouble. 

Assembly Process

Many parents get their crib, tear open the box, and rush to get the crib assembled. Although you may be eager to do the same, you should not! Taking the time to read and follow the manufacturer’s instructions is essential to ensure that the crib is assembled properly.

There may be minor steps, which you might skip if you ignored the instruction manual. Remember you can always contact the manufacturer directly if you need assistance with the assembly process. 

Bottom Sheet

You will not want your toddler to sleep directly on the mattress, so covering it with a sheet is a good idea. Adults might like the idea of utilizing several sheets, but this is not safe for toddlers.

In a crib, there should only be one sheet and it should be snuggly tucked into the mattress. All bumps and ripples should be eliminated. Make sure the sheet will remain in place throughout the night regardless of how much your toddler tosses and turns. 

Sleep Positioners

A lot of parents like the idea of sleep positioners, because they help to keep the child on their back. Although they can serve this purpose, they’re actually more problematic than you think. Small babies don’t need this accessory and babies, who are capable of rolling over, won’t either. Therefore, the sleep positioner is actually more harmful than good.

Leave a Comment